Restaurants in Fire Island
View MapFilters
Island Breeze
Feel the breeze
Island Breeze is an ideal low-key spot to grab an intimate bite and feel the sun on your shoulders.
Cherry Grove · 178 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove Pizza
The only pizza in town, and it's good.
Great garlic knot pies and near all the other gay bars and restaurants
Cherry Grove · 179 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove
Pines Bistro & Martini Bar
Splurge!
Though it'll set you back a few, the Pines Bistro consistently serves up quality dishes to plenty of fancy pines boys.
Fire Island Pines · 36 Fire Island Blvd., Fire Island Pines
The Blue Whale
Fire Island food destination
Enjoy a leisurely brunch or a dinner right in the Pines Harbor. The restaurant reflects the islands casual beach...
Fire Island Pines · Harbor Walk, Sayville
Canteen
Lunch by the harbor
Canteen is a great spot if you need a quick bite or want to grab a drink and settle next to the pool. It's one of the...
Fire Island Pines · Harbor Park, Fire Island
